Rate my Scenarios

[Stefan Härtel]

Before releasing any further scenarios, I have decided to let the people rate my recent works. The scenarios I would like you to rate are all available at http://members.xoom.com/SHaertel/Scenarios.html
You don't need to play the whole things through (I guess), but please take time to play a couple of turns and answer following questions:

1. Which of my scenarios do you like best?
2. Which of my scenarios do you like least?
3. Which scenario style do you like best?
4. Which scenario style do you like least?
5. Which topic do you like best? (Please name only one title)
6. Which topic do you like least? (Please name only one title)
7. How would you rate my overall work:
Excellent
Good
Fair
Poor
Terrible
(Please be honest)
I will not write my own opinion here because I'm not neutral, and I do not want to influence anyone's opinions in any ways.
Please, since I drew up the questions myself, there's no way to offend or insult me. Please be honest in your answers.
And please take time to answer at least some questions!
Thanx.


------------------
Follow the masses!
30,000 lemmings can't be wrong!

Mighty Carthage fought three wars:
It was still mighty after the first one, still inhabitable
after the second one;
It could not be found after the third one.
-Bert Brecht

Visit my Homepage at: http://members.xoom.com/SHaertel/Index.html

[VietMinh]

1.Artaxerxes
2.Parsa; Quest for Asia
3.Artaxerxes; simple yet not too much
4.Darius 2.0,2.2 though 2.2 was a good scn
5.Ancient Greece
6.Central Asia
7.Excellent

By the way I would like to playtest your upcoming scn.

DaiVietVu@netscape.net

[Stefan Härtel]

VietMinh: Sure you cann playtest my new scenario! I'll mail you sometime later and tell you what it is

And in the meantime: People, please take this bit of time, it means really much to me!

[Leonidas]

Stefan:

All your scenarios show excellent attention to detail -the quality and thought put into them shows. I have all of your scenarios, and although I have not played any of them through yet (big time factor), you can be sure that I will I am in the process of collecting the best scenarios off the web. Many of your scenarios are true classics.

I would rate them as excellent overall - please keep up the great effort you have shown.

[Squonk]

Hi

1. Which of my scenarios do you like best?
Mughals

2. Which of my scenarios do you like least?
Crusades?

3. Which scenario style do you like best?
3d Punic War?

4. Which scenario style do you like least?
Crusades?

5. Which topic do you like best?
Crusades (the topic) I like very much,
but if the question is what should be the topic
of the next scn, I would love to see you making
a scenario about late non-islamic Persia, f.e.
Byzantine-Persian war of Chosroes II and the
fall of Sasanids. Well, I wanted to make a scenario
about that from byzantine side, but probably never will,
so...
Or maybe Carthago?

6. Which topic do you like least? (Please name only one title)
Very early Persia.
It was a great scenario, though.

7. How would you rate my overall work:
Excellent

(Please be honest)
am
(as always; look down)

Follow the masses!
30,000 lemmings can't be wrong!

"30,000 lemings were sent to do the will of one
His claim was phrased quite simply, though he never voiced it loud
I am he, the chosen one"
(mod. "One for the vine")

I'm not voicing it loud...
But...

VietMinh
By the way I would like to playtest your upcoming scn.

..................................................
........................................ ... .
... ... ... ... ............ .... . . .
.. ..... .. .. .. .. .. ........... .... . .
.. .. .. ... ... ................. . .
... ... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .... .
........................................ . .
..................................................

[St Leo]

Some of you[r] recent scenarios suffer from the John Ellis syndrome.

------------------
St. Leo http://ziggurat.sidgames.com/ http://www.sidgames.com/forums/
[This message has been edited by St Leo (edited October 18, 2000).]

[Fiera]

quote: Originally posted by St Leo on 10-14-2000 09:14 PM Some of you recent scenarios suffer from the John Ellis syndrome.

Hmm... just curious... what is exactly the John Ellis syndrome?

[Sloth]

7. Excellent

[Cam]

quote: Originally posted by Fiera on 10-14-2000 09:19 PM Hmm... just curious... what is exactly the John Ellis syndrome?

I think what is meant is; a very large number of units and cities but often not with a terribly involved events file. Some people like that type of game, while others don't. John put together some huge campaign scenarios in Civ2's "early days" which usually included some outstanding artwork.

[This message has been edited by Cam (edited October 16, 2000).]

[Hendrik the Great]

Most of your scenarios are very good. I didn't like the Holy Wars that much. But for the rest it is just too hard to decide.

------------------
Mathias' Civ II Page
http://members.nbci.com/thalys

[Prometeus]

Don't be so unpolite with John Ellis' stuff, dude... I think Stefan really likes to do a lot of research before starting a scenario making; the same as me... Often that kind of scen are a result of that great research work ( look at my Antigonos )...

BTW all of your scenarios are great, Stefan: i begun to play your Shaibani yesterday, it's simply amazing for perfection!!! It's nearly impossible to say what's or isn't good of them... Maybe just Holy Wars, but that's all IMHO...
Best regards, Prometeus

[Stefan Härtel]

*bump*
Just thought this thread could be on top again

Thanks for all your comments so far.

Prometeus: Yes, I do a lot of research for my scenarios. As a matter of fact, that is the most fun part!

[Prometeus]

Sure, of course it's that the funniest part !!!!
[This message has been edited by Prometeus (edited October 26, 2000).]