New Mafia Scoring system discussion

[joncha]

The only rule I know is that ljcvetko is always the third mafia. He should be voted out as soon as possible.

[Rasputin]

yes his "false" leads i nrecent game have been very misleading ...

[Ljube]

I've done the score sheet up to mafia 18, but I can't post it yet cause html is not my greatest skill and I can't reduce my file bellow 20k characters yet. I'll have to use Jamski's table but it takes time. Let me just tell you all that Kassiopeia leads with 13 points out of 14 games while Guynemer is good second with 11 points and alva holds the third place with 10 points.

I'll post the entire table later.

[Ljube]

OK, it's too much hassle to use Jamski's table, so I'll post without formatting.

First the number of games played.

ADG and Skanky Burns played all games

ADG 17
Skanky Burns 17
rah 16
alva 14
Guynemer 14
Kassiopeia 14
Spaced Cowboy 14
DrSpike/Doc 13
Jon Miller 13
Zopperoni 12
GhengisFarb 11
Jamski 11
MattH 11
Pave 11
Spiffor 10
Tuberski/Deathtongue 10
Vlad Antlerkov 10
Jonny 9
vovansim/vovan 9
Comrade Tassadar 8
Drogue 8
Frozzy 8
Hercules 8
Theben 8
FlameFlash 7
Osweld/General Ludd 7
CaptainGarlic 6
Duke o'York 6
gjramsey 6
HongHu 5
Rasputin 5
Chaunk 4
GeneralTacticus 4
Nikolai 4
Nuclear Master 4
Azazel 3
joncha 3
Kropotkin 3
ljcvetko 3
mart7x5 3
Sandman 3
flipside 2
SnowFire 2
Urban Ranger 2
anZac 1
Asmodean 1
Boshko 1
china_444 1
Felch 1
MrBaggins 1
Naevrod 1
Sore Loser 1
Stormbringer 1
yaroslav 1


Second, the gamemasters.

Sheep 1
Sheep 2
Sheep 3
Tuberski, Sheep, Skanky 4
alva 5
Spaced Cowboy 6
vovan 7
vovan 8
Zopperoni 9
Kassiopeia 10
Frozzy 11
Jamski 13
Jamski 14
Jamski 15
Jamski 16
Jamski 17
Jamski 18

Hail Jamski! But he missed mafia 12


Third mafias in each game.

Jamski 1
DrSpike/Doc 17
Skanky Burns 6; 11
Spaced Cowboy 5
ADG 10; 13; 17
vovansim/vovan 10
Tuberski/Deathtongue 3; 15
Pave 6
Comrade Tassadar 2
rah 8
Guynemer 7
Kassiopeia 15
Asmodean 4
Zopperoni 11
Spiffor 18
CaptainGarlic 8
Jonny 9
HongHu 9; 16
Rasputin 13; 14
gjramsey 14; 18
Urban Ranger 15
joncha 16

Hail to Jamski again for winning the first game


Finally the points.
I calculated the points like this: If mafia survived they got one point. If mafia killed the other mafia they got one point. If one mafia was killed, alive villages got a point regardless of their voting.
These were the initial rules. However, to reward the winning mafia, I can increase their bonus to 5 points, which I think is the appropriate award.

Kassiopeia 13
Guynemer 11
alva 10
Spaced Cowboy 9
ADG 8
rah 8
Zopperoni 8
DrSpike/Doc 7
Jon Miller 7
MattH 7
Skanky Burns 7
FlameFlash 6
Hercules 6
Jamski 6
Jonny 6
Spiffor 6
Theben 6
gjramsey 5
Drogue 4
Frozzy 4
Osweld/General Ludd 4
Pave 4
Vlad Antlerkov 4
CaptainGarlic 3
Comrade Tassadar 3
Duke o'York 3
GhengisFarb 3
HongHu 3
Nikolai 3
SnowFire 3
Tuberski/Deathtongue 3
mart7x5 2
Sandman 2
vovansim/vovan 2
Asmodean 1
Chaunk 1
Felch 1
joncha 1
Kropotkin 1
ljcvetko 1
MrBaggins 1
Nuclear Master 1
Rasputin 1
Urban Ranger 1
anZac 0
Azazel 0
Boshko 0
china_444 0
flipside 0
GeneralTacticus 0
Naevrod 0
Sore Loser 0
Stormbringer 0
yaroslav 0

We can use this score sheet as starting point for our new scoring system.

Or this alternate score sheet if the winning mafia is awarded 5 points.

Kassiopeia 13
Spaced Cowboy 13
Guynemer 11
alva 10
Jamski 10
gjramsey 9
ADG 8
rah 8
Zopperoni 8
Comrade Tassadar 7
DrSpike/Doc 7
Jon Miller 7
MattH 7
Skanky Burns 7
FlameFlash 6
Hercules 6
Jonny 6
Spiffor 6
Theben 6
Asmodean 5
Drogue 4
Frozzy 4
Osweld/General Ludd 4
Pave 4
Vlad Antlerkov 4
CaptainGarlic 3
Duke o'York 3
GhengisFarb 3
HongHu 3
Nikolai 3
SnowFire 3
Tuberski/Deathtongue 3
mart7x5 2
Sandman 2
vovansim/vovan 2
Chaunk 1
Felch 1
joncha 1
Kropotkin 1
ljcvetko 1
MrBaggins 1
Nuclear Master 1
Rasputin 1
Urban Ranger 1
anZac 0
Azazel 0
Boshko 0
china_444 0
flipside 0
GeneralTacticus 0
Naevrod 0
Sore Loser 0
Stormbringer 0
yaroslav 0

[Rasputin]

way too lucky way of scoring....


if i had time id do a comparison of my scorign suggestions....

[Adagio]

Wow... that must have taken quite some time

[Adagio]

Originally posted by ljcvetko
First the number of games played.

ADG and Skanky Burns played all games

Does this officially show I have no life?

[Skanky Burns]

Is that meant to imply that I also have no life?

[Adagio]

[Skanky Burns]

[DrSpike]

Originally posted by ADG
Wow... that must have taken quite some time

Indeed. Good job.

[Ljube]

Originally posted by Skanky Burns

Wow! What a dashing avatar

[DrSpike]

Did he get it from a toothpaste commercial or what?

[Ljube]

Originally posted by ADG
Wow... that must have taken quite some time

Yes it did. But I didn't have anything to do yesterday at work so I endeavoured to produce a score sheet for the benefit of us all.

[Skanky Burns]

Tis my charming visage, no less.