Tweet
The question has been raised if the President's name the capital poll complies with the constitution.
This hearing will last 3 days until January 21st, 9pm GMT, please discuss.
This hearing will last 3 days until January 21st, 9pm GMT, please discuss.
Originally posted by Martin Gühmann
Pedrunn started an official poll entitled: "OFFICIAL: Choose the city name (final)"
The first post of this post contains the following lines:
From hour constitution the first post has to contain the followling information:
The question was what should be the name of our capital as expressed in the title. The title implies that the poll is a poll for decission making. So nothing wrong with that even it is not explicitly mentioned.
But it doesn't contain a clear and unbiased explanation why he exactly selected the two given city names for the run of poll.
According to his post he based his decission on "[t]he two most voted city names", ok it was clear that he meant the two city names voted in the unofficial poll:
Poll: Name of our capital
But actual he should have mentioned it. But that is not the problem the real problem is that his explanation is not clear and unbiased. Actual it is wrong.
Here are the top city names voted for in the said unofficial poll:
Lemur City is number 6 on this list and not number 2. The aim of the said unofficial poll was to gather information. That could have been information on how we call our first city, then the name would have been El Dorado without any further disscussion or a run off poll, between a certain number of the first top city names. The number of the first top city names could have been 2, 6 or whatever, that depends on the choice of the creator of the runoff poll, but not taking number 1 and number 6.
The argument Pedrunn used to use Lemur City as an option was that a lot of citiziens voted for names with the Lemur reference, but this argument is invalid. The rhules of the said unofficial poll was that every citiziens has 120 points that he could allocate to the cities on the list given in that poll. So a citizien was able to allocate all his points like this:
Lemurtown 30
Lemurcak 30
Lemurkakton 30
Lemur City 30
So just another citicien has to do the same thing all the Lemur options had 240 points together. So the conclusion is that:
Lemurtown != Lemurcak
Lemurcak != Lemurkakton
Lemur City != Lemurtown
And so on. Note for nonslicers != means unequal.
So the only explanation one could has why Pedrunn choosed Lemur City for the runoff poll is that he neither likes El Dorado nor Gondolin. And it was also clear as Pedrunn posted the poll that there were many people who don't like El Dorado and would vote for something different see the last comments of the Poll: Name of our capital thread. However the result is according to Article IV Section 2a) of The Constitution of Lemuria a biased poll in favour of Lemur City.
As the poll is biased it is null and void and must be declared invalid, in addition we need a new poll about the name of our capital, of course a unbiased one that must contain at least the first two top voted city names in the Poll: Name of our capital poll started by Locutus. As the aim of this poll was to gather further information the creator of the unbiased poll is free to put more city names on the option list as long as these city names are the n top voted city names in the Poll: Name of our capital poll.
-Martin
Pedrunn started an official poll entitled: "OFFICIAL: Choose the city name (final)"
The first post of this post contains the following lines:
From hour constitution the first post has to contain the followling information:
The question was what should be the name of our capital as expressed in the title. The title implies that the poll is a poll for decission making. So nothing wrong with that even it is not explicitly mentioned.
But it doesn't contain a clear and unbiased explanation why he exactly selected the two given city names for the run of poll.
According to his post he based his decission on "[t]he two most voted city names", ok it was clear that he meant the two city names voted in the unofficial poll:
Poll: Name of our capital
But actual he should have mentioned it. But that is not the problem the real problem is that his explanation is not clear and unbiased. Actual it is wrong.
Here are the top city names voted for in the said unofficial poll:
Code:
1. El Dorado................154 (6) 2. Gondolin.................134 (5) 3. Valhalla.................124 (5) 4. Paititi..................120 (4) 5. Xanadu...................119 (5) 6. Lemur City...............100 (4)
The argument Pedrunn used to use Lemur City as an option was that a lot of citiziens voted for names with the Lemur reference, but this argument is invalid. The rhules of the said unofficial poll was that every citiziens has 120 points that he could allocate to the cities on the list given in that poll. So a citizien was able to allocate all his points like this:
Lemurtown 30
Lemurcak 30
Lemurkakton 30
Lemur City 30
So just another citicien has to do the same thing all the Lemur options had 240 points together. So the conclusion is that:
Lemurtown != Lemurcak
Lemurcak != Lemurkakton
Lemur City != Lemurtown
And so on. Note for nonslicers != means unequal.
So the only explanation one could has why Pedrunn choosed Lemur City for the runoff poll is that he neither likes El Dorado nor Gondolin. And it was also clear as Pedrunn posted the poll that there were many people who don't like El Dorado and would vote for something different see the last comments of the Poll: Name of our capital thread. However the result is according to Article IV Section 2a) of The Constitution of Lemuria a biased poll in favour of Lemur City.
As the poll is biased it is null and void and must be declared invalid, in addition we need a new poll about the name of our capital, of course a unbiased one that must contain at least the first two top voted city names in the Poll: Name of our capital poll started by Locutus. As the aim of this poll was to gather further information the creator of the unbiased poll is free to put more city names on the option list as long as these city names are the n top voted city names in the Poll: Name of our capital poll.
-Martin
)...
I think we should use invented names and not phrases that state actual facts...
Comment