AMENDMENT: How to decide if an impeachment should occur?

[Frozzy]

IMO... we should have two polls.

Poll one: If the majority is Under 2/3, a second poll is conducted. If it is 2/3+, the impeachment occurs.

Poll2: If there is a straight majority, then the impeachment occurs.

[Pedrunn]

Are you guys changing your votes?

Redbull, the two polls looks redundant to me.

H tower, this means changing the section 3-III-e of the article: Polling. But could be managed! Looks logical. But still, why 2/3 rather than 1/2. why do you think the majority isnt enough?

Note: You must have at least 1/3 of all the citizens voting in the poll.

[H Tower]

because impeachment is a big thing, it shouldn't be easy to achieve. the 2/3 reflects that IMO

[Frozzy]

I think we are also forgetting that impeachment will be a rare occurence.

[Pedrunn]

Originally posted by H Tower
because impeachment is a big thing, it shouldn't be easy to achieve. the 2/3 reflects that IMO

After some thought it is a bad choice to declare the resolution poll to have 2/3 of the voters to pass. It just breaks the whole concept of being a poll to make the decisions of the community valid. Therefore it has to be decision of the > 50% (The least to have a majority) of the community at all.

I think we are also forgetting that impeachment will be a rare occurence.

I am sure it will be. I dont think one are going to have one at all. But still i wish if we had it was conducted by the people
I can live with Locutus system though.

[Pedrunn]

*bump*

Please, people vote. 10 voters is just too few. I know deciding a constitution isnt something that good as the nam or others things like the name and the flag. Actually is somethng very boring if you think it is just bureaucracy. But give your opinion.

H Tower and Redbull, do you guy want to change your votes to 'yes' even though the result of the mpeachment poll is > 50% of the community?

Vote Yes

[Gilgamensch]

Pedrunn, Yes I voted, but can't remember anymore what I voted, which is a shame

Let's hope they will during this days

[Devil of Truth]

Yes I voted No

[Pedrunn]

So i guess it is decided them.

Decision:
No - Someone can only be impeached if he inflicts the constitution.

Does anyone wants to express a change of the vote or a new vote?

[Locutus]

I think the number of voters is dwingling because it's taking too long to set up the game. We should really try to wrap things up within a week...

[Gilgamensch]

reminds me:

Locutus did you vote in the MAP-setting: number of cities threshold poll?