Pbem-bugs

[Borc]

How many PBEM-BUGS do you know already... and how many ways to cheat? I was very frustrated as i noticed that i can load a pbem save game as a single player game without any password restrictions :-/ i think it would be very important that all these bugs should be fixed with the next patch :-/ maybe we should make a bug list and send it to firaxis asap?

[Jon Shafer]

Firaxis is aware of that problem.

And yes, it is a problem. All those who play the game for each team make sure you load the game from the title screen. Beyond that, there's basically just 'annoyances' with PBEM. You can't see other civ's moves at all, even if they're within visible range. You don't see battles, you don't see anything like that. Therefore, cross-documentation between teams may be a good way to eliminate that problem (and a good way of recording the civss history).

[ZargonX]

So, would you recommend that there be a neutral "historian" to collect and record all of the teams moves? It does sound like a good idea, not only to prevent any mix-ups, but also just for posterities sake. Who knows, maybe there'll be some brilliant tactical moves that will forvever be emblazoned in Civ history

[Borc]

Nice to hear that firaxis knows the bug .

If i understand you in the right way your proposal means that Tribe A not only sends Tribe B the save-file but also a short summary about the military events... i.e.: "450 B.C. our swordsman attacked your city X and died..". (an action which Tribe B never would notice without this report)...

[Jon Shafer]

Exactly Borc.

The only potential problem I see is accurate reports, or them being too vague. It should be a unwritten (or written perhaps ) rule that the person that plays the turn for each team should write up a log for each part, and is required to inform a team if their units/civs/etc. was attacked on that turn.

A neutral historian could be found by some means to take in and organize all of the information collected by the team member playing the game, for some kind of historical log for the future.

[zeit]

Doing these kinds of reports should be the work of someone from each team- they organize the information coming from someone who played the game for their team, and divide it up:

1)reports for each civ: We attacked you, moved towards your city, pillaged this square, etc. These reprts are for the recipient team only, and it is free to do whatever it pleases with it (publish it, keep it secret)

2)Reports for your own members, includes all those reports that were sent to other teams, as well as reports recieved from the other teams. Also Any other important issues that aren't accesible to those who only have the save and for those who don't have it at all.

3)General reports for the community: some outlines should be agreed upon- What is everyone's right to know, or what is possible for anyone who plays SP game to know but not for PBEM player- like who builds which wonder, etc.

[Borc]

I am really frustrated... the bug i mentioned at the top of this thread was not fixed by firaxis newest patch 114f.
ITS SOOOOOO STUPID... i can load a pbem game which should be password protected and its NOOOT protected!
What a ***** can somebody explain how we can handle this?

[ruby_maser]

you don't see enemy "movements" but you still see the the enemy. If an enemy which you are at war with has a unit that is beside one of your units when you saved out and sent the game on, you should expect that you might get attacked prior to getting the game back. I'm not sure why someone would need to tell you these things.

[edit]: maybe that is a risk you take by sending forces out into the field... not having them report back in the next day

[Borc]

Thats not the problem...! i load the game (not from the title screen but from inside the game), just a click! and i see EVERYTHING! cheating is so easy that everybodywill cheat only because he is a bit tired or because he clicks on the wrong save game

[Zero]

Keeping a log sounds like a great idea. But just remember, don't report any moves that deals with other teams or the moves that they can't see

and well ruby here's a scenario... you are out at a field. When you moved up, the fog of war revealed both Lux armada and the GoS, your two most hated enemies. Your stack of 45 spearmen are gone. So is both the Lux and the GoS. Question remains then.. Did GoS defeat your stack and Lux conunter attack GoS's stack or did Lux struck your stack retreated and GoS took another path out of your field of view? Or did GoS attack yo, defeated and Lux mopped whatever that is left? Not having a log does make a considerbale amount of confusion.

[Borc]

hm, obviously nobody sees the problem, i try it again:

1) i already have a ptw game open
2) you send me your pbem save file
3) i save the file into the .../civ3/civ3ptw/saves/ folder
4) i switch back to my civ game
5) i think: "what a stupid game do i play! wouldn't it be much more fun to load the pbem game instead ...!"
6) i chose the option "load game" and (because i did not load the save file from the title screen) what do i see? YOUR CAPITAL, YOUR CIV, EVERYTHING!

[redstar1]

Borc: Yeah we know. Just keep repeating it until everyone knows exactly how do do it :P

[Borc]

redstar: if it would be hidden & secret then i would be very quiet! believe me... but the problem is so evident that all team leaders should discuss it asap... if 50 players will load the start position next week how many of them you think will make it in the wrong way???

why do we have secret forums if the save file is not save!

[FrustratedPoet]

We are going to have to trust people.

Anbody who cheats deliberately is a dirty rotten cheating evil cheat.

The biggest problem is that somebody will quite innocently load up the save game the wrong way and spoil things. I can't see anything we can do to stop this happening. Accidents will happen.

What do you think we can do to stop this Borc? That's the way the game is right now, we can't change it because we're not Firaxis.

Everybody should be very very careful.

[Borc]

my small idea is that every team gives the save file only to very very few ministers... and that they all concentrate on making screenshots for their team members... and we all have to make sure that firaxis tries to fix this stupid little bug for the next patch... if anybody here has some good connections to firaxis, please help...!