What do you rate PTW

[Flesh Reaver]

I gave it a 1.

I bought it for the MP, and that simply does not work.

I see all the other features (8 new civs, additional buttons, ect...) as icing on the cake.

Too bad the cake fell in the oven.

[Nevs23]

7

[Sandy]

8, has potential for 10.

I think that changing Civ 3 which is inherently sequential single player to multiplayer (PTW), will have big issues with synchronisation.

[WarpStorm]

Originally posted by Cidifer
if you haven't noticed problems with certain new units\civs then either your lucky or you haven't gotten all the way through a couple games to more modern things.

I'd like some specifics. I've played loads of games through to the modern age and I'd like to know what these errors are so that they can get fixed.

[Grungy]

SP = 10

MP = 5 I can get into games, takes time to find one to work and Laggy

Give MP a 10 when they fix it

[Fatwreck]

when a company says "hey this is a multiplayer expansion with some new cool singleplayer features" and the multiplayer does´nt work very well for most people then a game can´t get more than a 1... they should not have an oppurtunity to "fix" things it should have been done...I don´t want a million patches I want my game!

[Berduin]

I gave it a 7 only because I like the SP additions, but MP in its current state is unplayable. They should patch it quickly.

[Harovan]

SP 9. Still some things are missing.
MP 3. At most.

Average 6.

[Coracle]

Yikes!! 27.45% gave it the LOWEST possible rating!?!

Man, Firaxis is sinking to lows even I never expected.

[Coracle]

Originally posted by Fatwreck
... they should not have an oppurtunity to "fix" things it should have been done...I don´t want a million patches I want my game!

Indeed. With PTW, and with Civ 3.

What Firaxis has done this past year is inexcusable.

[statusperfect]

Originally posted by Coracle
What Firaxis has done this past year is inexcusable.

WTF are you talking about? It's just a cheap piece of gaming software. Sometimes you make it sound like Firaxis is murdering babies or something.

[Harovan]

What Firaxis has done this past year is inexcusable.

Why, they even included an option to turn culture flipping off. Who was it again, who demanded this about a thousand times? SP is near to perfect now (well, in Civ3 terms that is). MP needs some serious tweaks.

[GhengisFarbâ„¢]

I'm hopeful the MP issues will be addressed but MP is far more playable than SP was initially.

[Kramsib]

It is unbelievable , creating a multiplayer expansion which has everything except multiplayer.

Too fast, too bad. That is not the way to create good games.

[War4ever]

yeah , the mp part is glitchy at besst,,, for sp mode, this expansion set should have been included in the first release

but i hope future patches will help it out