Team Voting: Battle Log

[Jon Shafer]

This is a manual vote for what the team's prefer on the issue of a mandatory battle log. As there are 6 teams left, there is the possibility of a split vote. In that case, I'll have to think about what to do to solve that problem.

A battle log records just that - all the battles that took place on a team's turn with another team and how they ended. This information would be shared with the other team that was attacked via email or private message.

I'll keep this "poll" open for 7 days, giving the teams enough time to debate the issue and submit their votes. Whichever option wins will be added to the official "rules document" which will be voted on in turn in a couple weeks.

So:

Should a battle log be required to be sent to a team attacked by another team?

Each team may Approve, Disapprove or Abstain.

[Jon Shafer]

Poll ends in approximately 40 hours.

[Arnelos]

Due to internal polling, RP Team votes yes on this proposal.

[DeepO]

Gathering Storm votes "no" to this poll.

BTW, it's strange to see all our members having the same opinion on all 3 polls: there was only one vote contra the group, and even that one was not extreme, and could be lived with either way.

DeepO

[vondrack]

Legoland abstains on the matter of battle logs.

[Arnelos]

Well, GS, Legoland, and RP have voted on all issues.

Where are ND, Vox, and "Team" Master Zen?

[Panzer32]

2 people have voted on the issues in GoW, neither of them are Master Zen.

[Hot_Enamel]

Official Vote from Team GoW (So Far)


2 x No
1 x Dont Care
1 x Blah Blah Blah and Blah ....


The No vote is winning

{edit - Updated and the No vote is pulling ahead}

[Master Zen]

surprise: NO

[Darekill]

ND votes for: Approve

[Rhothaerill]

Vox Controli votes yes on battle logs.

[Jon Shafer]

All 6 teams have now voted.

3 teams for Approve, 2 teams for Disapprove, 1 team Abstains.

Battle logs have been approved.

[Panzer32]

guess thats it for me ever becoming emperor again.

[UnOrthOdOx]

Me as well.


Not to mention that the majority of the teams DID NOT APPROVE of the logs. Majortiy rules is one thing 50% is quite another. no, I'm never letting that personal grudge on the abstain drop. This is the perfect case for it. There is a clear and defined quorum, and the rule did not gain over 50% approved. It should not be passed as a result.