Which would make the better civ?

[ntyatecafe]

Out of curiosity (despite what it did to the cat), I'm starting a poll to see what everyone thinks would make the better civ for game mods.

[Trifna]

I would espescially look after a mod based on Tolkien or Frank Herbert's Dune. Or someone with a nice litteral mind that would build something that's not candies.

[ntyatecafe]

Originally posted by Trifna
I would espescially look after a mod based on Tolkien or Frank Herbert's Dune. Or someone with a nice litteral mind that would build something that's not candies.

Very good idea! Tokien & Herbert are very good for building a lot of background and developement into their works. Have you read any of Robert Jordan's works?

[Zealot]

Originally posted by Trifna
I would espescially look after a mod based on Tolkien or Frank Herbert's Dune. Or someone with a nice litteral mind that would build something that's not candies.

Well chosen, Trifna.

[LarryBernard]

Originally posted by Trifna
I would espescially look after a mod based on Tolkien or Frank Herbert's Dune. Or someone with a nice litteral mind that would build something that's not candies.

I'd like something which explains how the empire of mankind in dune gets where it is

[Quasar1011]

Other

I voted for "other", and you said to post an explanation. Guess mine is semi-fictional. I spent the first 8 years of my life in Pennsylvania, so I play as the Sylvanian civ. City names are taken from towns/roads/rivers/landmarks/people/mountains in Pennsylvania. Leader names are taken from my male ancestors, plus my son. I replaced the Iroqouis in the civ3mod.bic file to include this civ.
-Daryl of the Sylvanians

[BeBMan]

I would be happier with this poll if multiple selections would be allowed I mean, it is difficult to say that civ would be better only with one type of civs... The same goes for mods, I like historical, but also scifi...

[August Borms]

Hmm, all of them, except current, alternate reality and alien/futuristic civs.

But I voted for historic.

[Dauphin]

Allternate reality civs.

I would like to have scenarios that are similar but not quite the same as reality.

A three way Cold Wa, set in 1960, between the 3rd Reich, the USSR and USA would be interesting.

[fezick31]

I voted Other, as I often play as a civ that I make up (much like quasar1011). For example, i'm in a game of civ2 (civ3 doesn't run on my work computer, too slow) as the K'ta Linieri. It would be cool to be able to make up entirely ficticious civs

[Fresno]

Historic, absolutely.

[DrFell]

Historic or current. None of this fictional BS

[Fresno]

Now 54% thinks historic civs should be in...

Then why people keep saying civ isn't about history?

[Anodyne]

I'd say historic AND current civs (thus I didn't vote at all)

[godinex]

I like the alternative relity, wonder....