Are the moderators here exaggerating a bit?

[Keygen]

I have a question to make.

I posted my two first threads today in OT and were both closed in 40 minutes.

I can understand the reason for closing the first one but I am not sure why the second had to be closed.

Is it forbitten asking about spamming or closing records?

I though that among several subjects in OT you can jerk around with questions like that. Is this forum a discussion for everything off (TBS) Topic or not?

As long as I don't flame, insult, swear or repeating a subject for no reason shouldn't I be free to post what ever I feel like?

Better make a thread of what is forbitten or not and top it.

And don't close it again without giving me a full explanation.

Thanks

[General Ludd]

I wonder how long this one will take.

[Provost Harrison]

They have a bit of a wasp up their arse when it comes to questions about spamming. Either that or they don't like the look of your face

[SlowwHand]

Before you're , how did you squeeze in a 3rd?

[Keygen]

Originally posted by Provost Harrison
They have a bit of a wasp up their arse when it comes to questions about spamming. Either that or they don't like the look of your face

But they haven't seen my face
Besides women do like my face
No, the face under my username isn't my face

Originally posted by SlowwHand
Before you're , how did you squeeze in a 3rd?

Why should I get baned? For asking?
This is a question, not a spamm!

[Bereta_Eder]

Keygen íïìßæù üôé ï óëïïõ÷áíô óå ñùôÜåé ðùò îåêßíçóåò êáé ôñßôï èÝìá (thread) óÞìåñá (ôï üñéï åßíáé äýï ôçí çìÝñá). ÖáíôÜæïìáé ðùò ðÝñáóáí ïé 24 þñåò...

Ôùñá ãé'áõôü ðïõ ñùôÜò ç áëÞèåéá åßíáé üôé êáé 'ãù ôï âñÞêá ëéãÜêé áäéêáéïëüãçôï íá óïõ êëåßóïõí áõôÜ ôá äýï èÝìáôá äåäïìÝíïõ ôïõ ãåíéêüôåñïõ ÷áìïý ðïõ ãßíåôáé åäþ ìÝóá êáèçìåñéíþò.

ÐÜíôùò áõôü ðïõ îÝñù óôá óßãïõñá åßíáé üôé åÜí êÜíåéò Ýíá èÝìá óôï apolyton community ìÜëëïí èá ÷ñåéáôåß íá óïõ áðáíôÞóïõí. ÓõíÞèùò ôÝôïéá åñùôÞìáôá ðåñß êëåéóßìáôïò èåìÜôùí Þ áðáãüñåõóçò (ban) óõæçôïýíôáé åêåß.

Éóùò óïõ áðáíôÞóïõí êáé åäþ.

Ïíôùò Þôáí ëéãÜêé êïõöü!

----
in greek - barbarian language detox --

[Ming]

If you have complaints about moderating practices... do a thread in the Apolyton forum, where that kind of discussion belongs...

Moved to apolyton forum.

[Keygen]

Äåí Þîåñá üôé õðÜñ÷åé üñéï óôá èÝìáôá ðïõ ìðïñåßò íá äçìïóéåýóåéò ôçí ìÝñá. Ìïõ öáßíåôáé ëßãï ãåëïßï áëëÜ öáíôÜæïìáé üôé åßíáé ðñïóôáóßá áðü áõôïýò ðïõ îåóêßæïíôáé íá äçìéïõñãïýí óõíÝ÷åéá êáéíïýñãéá èÝìáôá.

ÐÜíôïò åßíáé ãåëïßï ðïõ Ýêëåéóáí ôï äåýôåñï èÝìá.

OK, enough with the Greek

The subjects I posted were stupid but not a reason to be closed maybe with the exeption of the first one.

Here are the links to judge for yourself:

<a href="http://apolyton.net/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=28415">The greatest spammers of Apolyton!</a>
<a href="http://apolyton.net/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=28416">16 Minutes to close a thread!</a>

Another thread regarding me was closed immediately after:

<a href="http://apolyton.net/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=28417">Woo hoo! Record by Keygen ?</a>

Yes, stupid threads indeed but were subjects to be closed?
I don't want to make it a big deal but I am curious about what you can post in OT and what you cannot.
Is there any FAQ? If not would be possible to make one for the non-regular OT posters and the new ones?

My appologies Ming but if I was pain in the ass but you didn't answered to my question. I want an aswer primary from the OT moderators as they decide what to close and what they leave.

[tniem]

Those were all just spam fests and it appears this thread is heading for a similar feet.

But someone please look in the Civ 3 forum at the thread entitled "Finally..." It is the biggest on topic spamfest that I have ever seen continue for as long as it has.

[MichaeltheGreat]

tniem - It's dead, and the originator of it got a week vacation and 100% PCR. Yes, 100, not 10.

Some other megaspammers will be getting PCRs as well.

--------------------------------

Keygen - a thread to complain about a thread being closed may be one thing (if it's an actual complaint, as opposed to a spamfest)

A thread that is basically "hey, I got a thread closed in 16 minutes, is that some kind of record" with a bunch of people posting crap in it is just game playing - like the 50 or so "what is your favorite color" threads people have done.

[Solver]

Keygen, mate, what the heck with you? Uzvedies labi, vai pa purnu! Enough with Latvian .
Couldn't quite imagine you spamming, matey.

[Chris 62]

Well Kegan, even if they didn't close the first, I would have requested it.
Why?
I don't care to see my name in a poll, for one thing, for another, I already had a heated discussion with I guy who "hinted" I was a spammer based on PC.

The Posts per day talley does not reflect where you post.

I add atleast 5 posts per day in just the PBEM games I'm in (several), not to mention that I'm also a MP guy, into the scenario league, as well as commenting in the general area and other parts of the site, like the Spanish forum, the Civ-3 section, ect.

Bad form using posters names in polls, old boy.

[Keygen]

<i>tniem</i>, if I was feeling like spamming the hell out of it I would be emperor by now and not king.
It's up to the posters if a thread turns to spam fest and not to the one who posts the thread what ever his intentions are.


<i>MtG</i>, I admit that the first one was subject to be closed though it was not my intention to spam or promote flame.
I opened PH's profile and got amazed by the amount of posts per day and got that idea of posting a poll regarding posts per day. A little curious and a little teasing I could say. Bad idea I guess.

But I will disagree with you regarding the second thread.
What's the problem posting a thread with that subject?
I see dozens of stupid threads weekly that I would never bother to view. Most of them are not getting closed and some of them are getting very long.

I think that the often spam threads being posted have maken the OT moderators very suspicious but I don't blame you with all these crap you have to read every day

BTW, I didn't know that there is a restriction on thread posting per day in OT.


<i>Solver</i>, I wasn't spamming...
Or I though I wasn't


<i>Chris</i>, I wasn't meant to flame anyone therefore I appologize if I have offended you

And poster's name are used very often in thread titles or contents

[Ming]

Originally posted by Keygen
My appologies Ming but if I was pain in the ass but you didn't answered to my question. I want an aswer primary from the OT moderators as they decide what to close and what they leave.

Spam is a matter of opinion... it's that simple. We make the best decisions we can... and people will disagree. In most cases, when a thread is closed or deleted, somebody will whine about it.
Excuse us for not wasting more time by answering every whine

[red_jon]

BIG MING IS WATCHING YOU