Censorship

[M. le Comte]

I don't know why the Flashman's thread keep being closed.

I'm sure there were good reasons, I haven't read the closed thread anyway, but I trust the administrators of this site.

However

The last one, http://apolyton.net/forums/showthrea...threadid=25184 that as been closed too, was neither dangerous nor violent nor pornographic.

Why the hell was it closed ?
There was no reason to close that one. Was it a joke from MarkG ?

I dislike censorship anyway. I find people which put stars not to show a prohibed word are ridiculous. Mother ****er. So furthermore, when it comes to people compelled to silence because of the censor's goodwill, I become angry.

[Bugs ****ing Bunny]

I'd guess the thread was closed because it was a running joke. Personally I think MarkG's closing note just added the punchline. Turning it into a crusade would be a bit sad.

As for the autocensor? Not everyone wishes to read such words. You can either be a gentleman and live with it, or stick to obscenities the autocensor doesn't recognise.

I prefer the latter, obviously.

[Ming]

It was closed because there was no more need for discussion.
As MarkG pointed out, it was obvious why he was closing the thread.

Many of his threads which aren't rude or crude are just pure spam, which also aren't allowed under the current rules.

And feel free to get angry... it is your opinion, and I can understand where you are coming from.

However, this isn't a democracy... This is a private site. The owners make the rules. If you wish to be a member here, you are asked to follow them. It's that simple.

[Shadowstrike]

I find it quite ironic that my prediction that he wouldn't survive on Apolyton has errily come true. And yes, this is spam in disguise. Except you can't see it.

[DinoDoc]

MarkG is changing thread titles without any reasonable justification: http://apolyton.net/forums/showthrea...threadid=25336

Is it our fault his homeland is plagued with such horrible civil strife?

Macedonia rebels begin weapons surrender

[ColdWizard]

you could always go to ACOL, they believe in freedom

[tniem]

Totally not censorship. You can still read what was said in that thread. All Mark did was stop the spamming that was going on at the time to stop the +1 post count posts.

Of course anyone could start another thread on the subject if there was more to say on the topic other than speaking in third person. So you have and it probably wont be stopped because the site does allow most public discourse but spam threads have never been allowed and I hope will continue to be stopped.

[Lefty Scaevola]

Originally posted by ColdWizard
you could always go to ACOL, they believe in freedom

Except for one prominent scapegoat eliminated for conflict of personality.:banned:

[Asher]

Speaking of which, my buddy Mark just cleared all of my replies to a post of his thread regarding his ads.

Edit: Nevermind, he simply moved them to a new thread with an offensive title. It's ironic, because he just trolled.

[M. le Comte]

Re: Censorship

Originally posted by M. le Comte
Mother ****er.

I can't believe it !
I have been censored because I have written Mother F-u-c-k-e-r, enculeur de mère in French !
I believed only the American where puritan at this level. Are the Greeks afraid of that kind of language ?

I mean, I understand that Apolyton's owners censor spam threads or people who keep writting words as... see below.

But that kind of words are a part of the vocabulary. When you don't use them too often, they can show particularly strong feelings about a topic, express violence and so on ! But that just stays simple WORDS !

Furthermore, the way you use censorship is ridiculous. Because while putting little stars, you hide the word, but you can't wipe out the ideas included in that word.

That reminds me the Jerry I-don't-know-what show in America, of which I have whatched excerpts on TV. This Jerry machin-chose showed us the perversity of media, making money with people's problems, showing human as a monkey. But that was okay for the American puritan public, because noone could hear the insults (bip). Everyone could understand however.

You know how that kind of things are called in France ? HYPOCRISY

[Lefty Scaevola]

Richard Pryor* was at breakfast with his wife and baby son, and the cild spoke for the first time "mother". Pryor said to his wife, listen honey, junior knows half a word!

*famous foul mouthed commedian

[MarkG]

Re: Re: Censorship

Originally posted by M. le Comte
Because while putting little stars, you hide the word, but you can't wipe out the ideas included in that word

exactly. those who dont want to see the words dont read them. that doesnt mean that the message is not "given". everyone happy

[Chris 62]

The Flashman looks for trouble

This makes me think that a centain Gallic poster may indeed be the DL that many suspect.

Ninnyman/Pedro/Flashman knows his stuff is against the rules before he posts it, it's just a stupid game he likes to play, like talking in the third person.

you could always go to ACOL, they believe in freedom

Haven't been following trends the last few months?

[*End Is Forever*]

The autocensor is completely pointless. It's not like the intention or meaning of a word that is asterisked-out is not clear. So, basically, someone who gets offended by a word is going to get equally offended if it is censored (either that or they are a hypocrite)... but the autocensor has the added bonus of being patronising (yeah right, if I can only see asterisks I won't know what it means my arse!). So, rather than offending people, the autocensor ought to be offend and patronise people.

A word is just a collection of letters. It is the meaning of the word that may/may not be offensive. Therefore, anyone who is fine with the asterisks but not with the word itself is either incredibly stupid or a ****ing hypocrite.

[tniem]

Re: Re: Censorship

Originally posted by M. le Comte
But that kind of words are a part of the vocabulary. When you don't use them too often, they can show particularly strong feelings about a topic, express violence and so on ! But that just stays simple WORDS !

Actually I think it shows immaturity that you can't come up with a more appropriate way of showing your irritation or your dander.