Official: Worker placings, 2116

[Vlad Antlerkov]

Here's the current plan, with items in question in boldface. Vote whether you approve or disapprove of each section. If you disapprove, PLEASE post suggestions. It doesn't help if a majority disapproves, but no one in that majority suggests anything else.

New Apolyton

Worker 1: Nutrient tile (3/1/0)
Worker 2: Rolling/moist tile (1/1/0)
Worker 3: Mineral tile (0/3/0)

TBIBTU

Worker 1: Nutrient tile (3/0/0)
Worker 2: Rolling/moist river tile (1/1/1)
Worker 3: Any rolling/moist tile (1/1/0)

Base 3

Worker 1: Sea nutrient tile (4/0/0)
Worker 2: Any rolling/moist tile (1/1/0)

Base near the monoliths (if it gets built this term)

Worker 1: Monolith (2/2/2)
Worker 2: Monolith if in range, otherwise rolling/rainy tile (2/2/2; 2/1/0)

You have 3 days.

edit: added values from TKG's post

[Method]

to clarify:
(in the order Nut-Min-En. also correct me if i'm wrong on these)

New Apolyton

Worker 1: Nutrient tile: 3-1-0
Worker 2: Rolling/moist tile: 1-1-0
Worker 3: Mineral tile: 0-3-0

TBIBTU

Worker 1: Nutrient tile: 3-0-0
Worker 2: Rolling/moist river tile: 1-1-1
Worker 3: Any rolling/moist tile: 1-1-0

Base 3

Worker 1: Sea nutrient tile: 4-0-0
Worker 2: Any rolling/moist tile: 1-1-0

Base near the monoliths (if it gets built this term)

Worker 1: Monolith: 2-2-2
Worker 2: Monolith if in range, otherwise rolling/rainy tile: 2-1-0


oh, and i approve

[Vlad Antlerkov]

I see someone disapproves of part of the plan, yet neglected to make any suggestions.

Come on. Show yourself. Don't make me send my aide after you.

[AdamTG02]

I voted disapprove on New Apolyton. # minerals is good enough that we should take advantage of it as early as we can, while maintaining population growth. So for New Apolyton, my vote goes to take the 3 minerals second and the rolling/moist third.

Everything else, I apporve.

[Pandemoniak]

Same as Adam, lets get these minerals !!

[moomin]

I approved, because they seemed as good choises and generally I couldn't be arsed to tinker with it.

But I don't approve with this voting format - you need to specify alternative locations (2-3 that make some sort of sense) and poll for these instead of determining the poll from scratch in this fashion. There was never any chance of the approve alternatives biting the dust here, was there?

[Maniac]

I agree! It's a biased poll. One of the reasons I was that disapprover Vlad talks about.
More minerals to New Apolyton! It grows fast enough already.

[Pandemoniak]

It is indeed a biased poll.
Vlad, could you rather post a poll for each base, each option being a tile, allowing multiple vote : then, we'll harvest the tiles in descending order of votes. And you repoll at every turnchat.
How does that sound ?
Feedbakcs please.

[DeathByTheSword]

agree with pande

[Method]

pand

[Vlad Antlerkov]

Agreed. Next time, I'll think through a poll before posting it.

If I do this again, chances are you'll next find me posting my own resignation-- no poll, of course