The Angle Dispute Is Smoothed Over
Three days passed and once again the great leaders of Angleland returned to the gray stone castle along the Tim's river, proposals in hand. The various factions gathered in Camelot's great hall and presented their proposals to King Arthur.
First up, Mercia & Scotland, who the other Angles had labeled the Obtuse Faction, presented their proposal. As they had argued, their kingdoms should be seated closest to the King, as, they felt, their land had the most power and claim to such a high honor. Other representatives would descend from the head of the table in order of importance.
Next, Northumbria and East Anglia presented their proposal. They considered themselves the Right Faction, and felt that the existing table was just right and didn't need to be changed. Like the previous faction they put themselves nearest the head of the table and nearest to King Arthur.
While no one took them seriously, Wales also presented a proposal of their own. Standing alone, the others considered Wales to be a Cute Faction, and of little importance. They however held themselves in a might high regard and felt justified in placing Wales closest to the King.
Finally, Alfred of Wessex presented his proposal. His was radically different from the others. His table was round in design, and he strove for equality - not hierarchy with his design. Such a bold proposal attracted both interest and scorn from his compatriots.
King Arthur looked over all the proposals. He studied each carefully. Then he spoke.
Arthur - Alfred, I notice that the Obtuse, Right, and a Cute Factions are all in agreement that the Anglers, the scientists and the holy men are the least important members of the council and should be at the foot of the table. They may not agree on much, but on that point they have reached a consensus, do you believe all of them to be in error?
Alfred - I mean no disrespect, but yes, I believe they are.
Arthur - That is a rather brash thing to say. Land is power, we all know that. Even Sir Gawain of Wales understands that. Why do you believe otherwise?
Alfred - I don't dispute that land is power. I know that too well. However, if this council is to properly represent Angleland then it must represent more than just the powerful. Our merchants and our fisherman are vital to our strength and wealth. Without their shipping the goods of our land would rot at port. Without their food, our people would starve. Our scientists are vital to our future and our knowledge. Just the other day Roger Bacon was telling me about this marvelous new system of numbers he devised called mathematics. These numbers are already finding marvelously practical purposes, apparently this maths thing can increase the productivity of our lumberjacks! I don't know how, but it works! And finally, I believe Gildas and our holy men are essential both to represent our conscious and to speak on behalf of the gods. We must never lose sight of the divine. However as important as I feel they are, I never meant to suggest that they are more important than Northumbria, or Mercia, or Scotland or anywhere else. Only that all we gathered here in this council must share equal responsibility for leadership of our nation and be equally recognized for it. The table design, this round table, has no head and no foot. All who dine at it are equal.
Alfred waited nervously for the King to answer. He knew he was out of step with all the others, he knew he was taking a big chance with such a bold proposal, but he felt he must do what is right, no matter the result. If he angered the King... well it would certainly be unfortunate, but he was prepared to face the consequences. He tensed up as the King finally responded.
Arthur - Most interesting... most interesting indeed... this is not what I had in mind, but... you have impressed me noble Alfred. Our land is in need of original thinkers, and those who can bridge the divides of factions. It does seem that the hierarchy we cling to is driving the animosity. Your round table may indeed be the answer.
Alfred did his best not to look visibly relieved. He was glad the King saw the wisdom of his proposal. He was hopeful too the council could finally stop talking about tables and get down to the business of governing. The others were momentarily resentful their proposal was not chosen, but soon recognized the wisdom of the King's decision and the honorable stance of Alfred. None however anticipated what Arthur would say next.
Arthur - It is no surprise that I am quite old. In fact I don't expect I have much longer here on this Earth. That is, of course, why I have called his great council. Together this council is charged with leading and governing our fair people. You all must work together to see to the prosperity and health of our people. You must all fight for the strength and power of our kingdom. You all must rise to the occasion to slay our enemies, should any threaten our land and people. This council, this round table, shall control our nation from here in Camelot. However, unlike the noble Alfred I am not so convinced of the wisdom of total and absolute equality among all council members. One must be chosen to lead, to rule, and to handle our affairs with other nations. As I have no son, I have brought you here to observe you and to judge who among you is best to take this role and lead our people. Most of you fought amongst yourselves and jockeyed for power, it is only Lord Alfred who put aside his own ambition to suggest the fairest proposal for all. Thus it is he who shall succeed me to the throne, it is he who shall be King of Angleland.
Alfred and the rest of the council was stunned, but soon the applauded and congratulated Alfred. All were glad Angleland would have no succession crisis.
Three days passed and once again the great leaders of Angleland returned to the gray stone castle along the Tim's river, proposals in hand. The various factions gathered in Camelot's great hall and presented their proposals to King Arthur.
First up, Mercia & Scotland, who the other Angles had labeled the Obtuse Faction, presented their proposal. As they had argued, their kingdoms should be seated closest to the King, as, they felt, their land had the most power and claim to such a high honor. Other representatives would descend from the head of the table in order of importance.
Next, Northumbria and East Anglia presented their proposal. They considered themselves the Right Faction, and felt that the existing table was just right and didn't need to be changed. Like the previous faction they put themselves nearest the head of the table and nearest to King Arthur.
While no one took them seriously, Wales also presented a proposal of their own. Standing alone, the others considered Wales to be a Cute Faction, and of little importance. They however held themselves in a might high regard and felt justified in placing Wales closest to the King.
Finally, Alfred of Wessex presented his proposal. His was radically different from the others. His table was round in design, and he strove for equality - not hierarchy with his design. Such a bold proposal attracted both interest and scorn from his compatriots.
King Arthur looked over all the proposals. He studied each carefully. Then he spoke.
Arthur - Alfred, I notice that the Obtuse, Right, and a Cute Factions are all in agreement that the Anglers, the scientists and the holy men are the least important members of the council and should be at the foot of the table. They may not agree on much, but on that point they have reached a consensus, do you believe all of them to be in error?
Alfred - I mean no disrespect, but yes, I believe they are.
Arthur - That is a rather brash thing to say. Land is power, we all know that. Even Sir Gawain of Wales understands that. Why do you believe otherwise?
Alfred - I don't dispute that land is power. I know that too well. However, if this council is to properly represent Angleland then it must represent more than just the powerful. Our merchants and our fisherman are vital to our strength and wealth. Without their shipping the goods of our land would rot at port. Without their food, our people would starve. Our scientists are vital to our future and our knowledge. Just the other day Roger Bacon was telling me about this marvelous new system of numbers he devised called mathematics. These numbers are already finding marvelously practical purposes, apparently this maths thing can increase the productivity of our lumberjacks! I don't know how, but it works! And finally, I believe Gildas and our holy men are essential both to represent our conscious and to speak on behalf of the gods. We must never lose sight of the divine. However as important as I feel they are, I never meant to suggest that they are more important than Northumbria, or Mercia, or Scotland or anywhere else. Only that all we gathered here in this council must share equal responsibility for leadership of our nation and be equally recognized for it. The table design, this round table, has no head and no foot. All who dine at it are equal.
Alfred waited nervously for the King to answer. He knew he was out of step with all the others, he knew he was taking a big chance with such a bold proposal, but he felt he must do what is right, no matter the result. If he angered the King... well it would certainly be unfortunate, but he was prepared to face the consequences. He tensed up as the King finally responded.
Arthur - Most interesting... most interesting indeed... this is not what I had in mind, but... you have impressed me noble Alfred. Our land is in need of original thinkers, and those who can bridge the divides of factions. It does seem that the hierarchy we cling to is driving the animosity. Your round table may indeed be the answer.
Alfred did his best not to look visibly relieved. He was glad the King saw the wisdom of his proposal. He was hopeful too the council could finally stop talking about tables and get down to the business of governing. The others were momentarily resentful their proposal was not chosen, but soon recognized the wisdom of the King's decision and the honorable stance of Alfred. None however anticipated what Arthur would say next.
Arthur - It is no surprise that I am quite old. In fact I don't expect I have much longer here on this Earth. That is, of course, why I have called his great council. Together this council is charged with leading and governing our fair people. You all must work together to see to the prosperity and health of our people. You must all fight for the strength and power of our kingdom. You all must rise to the occasion to slay our enemies, should any threaten our land and people. This council, this round table, shall control our nation from here in Camelot. However, unlike the noble Alfred I am not so convinced of the wisdom of total and absolute equality among all council members. One must be chosen to lead, to rule, and to handle our affairs with other nations. As I have no son, I have brought you here to observe you and to judge who among you is best to take this role and lead our people. Most of you fought amongst yourselves and jockeyed for power, it is only Lord Alfred who put aside his own ambition to suggest the fairest proposal for all. Thus it is he who shall succeed me to the throne, it is he who shall be King of Angleland.
Alfred and the rest of the council was stunned, but soon the applauded and congratulated Alfred. All were glad Angleland would have no succession crisis.
Comment