Originally posted by Pitboss Maya
I'm not disbanding the unit.
1. As Japan pointed out, Rome double moved against me, and no penalty was assessed. I could have made the same argument that it affected my stratagy.
2. No clear penalty was ever spelled out. This punish as we go mentality is problematic.
3. According to this, anyone involved in a war has to wait 6 hours. I don't know if this is the intent of the rule, but that is how I interperate it. How are we defining "last move"? This rule does not mention ending turn at all.
I'm not disbanding the unit.
1. As Japan pointed out, Rome double moved against me, and no penalty was assessed. I could have made the same argument that it affected my stratagy.
2. No clear penalty was ever spelled out. This punish as we go mentality is problematic.
3. According to this, anyone involved in a war has to wait 6 hours. I don't know if this is the intent of the rule, but that is how I interperate it. How are we defining "last move"? This rule does not mention ending turn at all.
Not to mention that it's a bit immature to refer back now to something in the past about which you said that it was ok.
2. I have always said that we are mature people and should decide on concequences based on situations, and not pre-set a penalty for all situations.
Apparantly I was wrong and we are not dealing here with mature people but with childish people who are not able to admit that there was a mistake and accept the (Small) concequences.
Well, that means that The Capo was right and I was wrong. Bring on your harsh penalties, Capo. I'll vote in favour of it. I'm sorry that I voted against it fist, I had no idea that we were dealing with little children.
3. Yes, we have made a clear agreement on this a couple of days ago. Not to mention that everyone knew that these things were hot debated. And that even without all those fairly new rules, the old rule would simply say: the person who voted last in the last turn will not vote first in the new turn.
Dude, please make now a comment that show that all my comments about you were unfair and out of place, and just deal with a mistake you made. There's no problem with making mistakes.
The question is not: do we make mistakes, but: how do we deal with our mistakes.
The outcome of that is if we need The Capo's hard penalty system for children or a system based on reasonable mature people.
And I am really prepared to accept The Capo's system if it apears that he was right, and you are not able to handle this thing reasonable.
Yes, I'm quite angry.
Comment