Are combat odds flawed in PBEM?

[bongo]

Just having a rather odd string of combat result in a PBEM. After my opponent killed a bunch of my units without losing a single units I entered "whining mode" about what I viewed as unatural good luck on his part. This got him checking *all* combats in our war and he found that in *all* fights where the odds of winning was above 50%, the attacker won.

There has been 17 such fight so far. While this may not be enough to call statistically significant I still find it very weird.

Anyone seen anything like this before? Is this a bug or are are we just having an insane streak of pRNG results?

(we play vanilla civ4 btw, Edit: it's patch 1.61)

[bongo]

Can also add that attacks with bad odds (below 50%) seems to work as expected, in other words, you lose most of the time.

[Paddy]

heres hoping it not on warlords

[bongo]

Does anyone have old vanilla civ4 saves they can check to see if I'm alone?