Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
The Moral Arc
Collapse
X
-
After witnessing the jewish museum of the holocaust in salonica I will not call anyone nazi but the germans.
- Likes 2
-
Why do you call them "very progressive?" I have a good friend who is very progressive. I don't have any friends of the type of people you are speaking about. I have one friend on facebook like that, but I keep him because he responds to my posts which keeps them on top of the feed. But he thinks I'm insensitive too, which is the basis for calling people who think differently than you racist, misogynist, Islamophobe etc...Originally posted by Elok View PostSo, I have once again made the fatuous mistake of trying to converse with hardcore progressives on FB. I honestly tried to be open and fair, which was stupid but seemed to begin well. I probably shouldn't have even touched a thread where an old college friend of mine, who is a very nice and very progressive person, asked people to talk about their feelings now that Trump was about to take over and start hunting lesbians for sport. There was a great deal of feeling unsafe and crying about lost futures and WHY DOES EVERYONE HATE US, and let's just say it went slowly downhill until I got chastised for insensitivity and had the sense to bow out before I got compared to Hitler.
I'm still not totally clear about why people are still acting this catatonically upset two months on. If I am to take these claims at face value, they are feeling and acting about how I would six months after my mother died in a horrible wreck. If Hillary had won, the hardcore conservatives would be forming militias, stockpiling ammo, and doing other demented but arguably sorta constructive things. Their general mentality would be "**** THAT WORTHLESS WHORE WE'LL SHOW HER." These folks are, well, hugging their teddies in the safe space. Why?
The simplest, but most mean-spirited explanation is that this is a manifestation of what the Atlantic last year summed up as "victim culture," wherein Young People These Days compete to be the most oppressed and therefore most entitled to attention and vengeance from an external source of authority or validation, yadda yadda. In other words, it's a kind of play-act. But that would require me to believe that it's all basically insincere. So I'm going to proceed on the assumption that this is sincere, but that these people are not the utter ninnies that would seem to imply.
My most promising theory is that these folks really believe in something like MLK's "moral arc of the universe," wherein it's somehow natural for things to continually get better a little bit at a time, with some minor backsliding to be expected. Hillary was a sequel to Obama, a pinnacle of the Fezzian moral vision where the first woman president succeeds the first black president and rights for everyone get all the way better--basically, they're approaching the liberal-prog singularity. Past the curve in the hockey stick. But then, somehow, a parody of Republicanism so grotesque that even Republicans don't like him swoops in and steals her place. They're upset about their jeopardized gay marriages and abortions and Hamilton performances and stuff, but more than that, they're upset because this upsets their understanding of how the story is supposed to go. The universe is all wrong now. The math isn't adding up anymore. They feel like I feel when human beings do the right thing without profit motive, but much more so. They've attempted to make it right by inventing horse**** about Russian "hacking" or trying to subvert the Electoral College (or just blaming it, like a three million margin on the gilded turd is something to be proud of). I thought it was about Trump himself, but I wonder if it's more like disappointed believers redoing their math from Revelation so the end of the world prediction might not be a total fizzle after all.
Your thoughts? Also, for extra credit, is there an interpretation of the whole "privilege" concept that is not essentially about constructing an inverted status hierarchy and forcing the less crippled *****es to know their place when the big kids are talking?
Is it because you are a true traditionalist? Or maybe you are saying that so not to offend the majority here. If the latter, why do you think it is offensive to not call these people what they are?
Leave a comment:
-
Yes.Originally posted by giblets View Post
Are you serious?
There were basically none before 1970, and post 1970 there were a few of limited attacks against those that promoted homosexuality as an acceptable lifestyle and part of culture (so these could be considered as a violent response to a nonviolent attack on the common culture) and not an open broad attack against homosexual people (which would be against closeted people too).
There was never anything like what happened in Nazi Germany (unlike what the US did to the Japanese and Native Americans) or against the African Americans. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persec..._the_Holocaust for example of a sustained open attack against homosexuals (some African countries may be trying to copy).
JM
Leave a comment:
-
Here's the thing about safe spaces, they are an undemocratic way to push people around and get more power.Originally posted by Lorizael View Post
Well, I just got through receiving an education at a bastion of liberal, coastal elites and never once encountered a safe space.
But here's the thing about safe spaces, guys: it's just making explicit a real and uncontroversial aspect of our psychological needs. If you spend 8 hours a day with an ******* boss and incompetent coworkers and then have an hour long drive home through ferocious traffic, but then you get home and feel comfortable and loved and valued, congratulations, that's your ****ing safe space. This idea that we need to put on our big boy pants because the real world is a mean place is bull****, because all of us have a place we go to when we're ****ing tired of dealing with the real world.
Except, actually, not all of us do. If you are a battered spouse or a gay kid with homophobic parents or what have you, then maybe not even home is a safe space. Then you rely on other spaces, either ones provided by the community or by friends or like-minded individuals.
Do maybe some people take this notion and run with it and talk about providing safe spaces from the great injustice of being mildly offended? Maybe. But who gives a ****? Stop getting so goddamn worked up when other dumb people do a dumb thing. Learn to roll your ****ing eyes and move on. Don't go whining about how the whole world has gone soft and kids these days and bla bla bla, because then you know what? Then you're waaaaaay overreacting to a minor problem, and hey what the hell does that sound like?
(The "you" here is not aimed at anyone here, but at the people I see on Facebook and Twitter who get frothy about this kind of stuff. This probably comes across as way harsher than I intended. But I'm tired and kind of in a bad mood for completely unrelated reasons, so I'm just going to hit post reply now and see what happens. Sorry.)
Leave a comment:
-
He's not going to be terrible at all. I think the guy is rude, and it bothers me that people supported him over Cruz, but maybe it's for the best. He should be a good leader I'm, maybe even great. Rudeness really doesn't matter.Originally posted by Aeson View PostThe danger with Trump is perhaps longer term it the R machine accepts they have to play Trumps game to stay relevant. That is something that on a longer timeframe might lead to a generation where closer to half the population would follow a Trump like figure down the rabbit hole.
So really we should probably root for Trump to be as terrible as people fear he will be.
Leave a comment:
-
I wouldn't go as far as JM does there, but gays probably have far less to fear from Trump than, say, Muslims. Mind you, I've no idea how Muslims are reacting to all this. But even illegal immigrants face a much bigger challenge. Religious conservatives are in the back of the Trump bus, and they're only there because nobody else would take them.
Leave a comment:
-
Are you serious?white homosexuals who have never experienced a sustained open attack against their lives and property in US history.
Leave a comment:
-
Well, I just got through receiving an education at a bastion of liberal, coastal elites and never once encountered a safe space.Originally posted by The Mad Monk View Post"Safe spaces" is something that appears to be encouraged on college campuses these days.
But here's the thing about safe spaces, guys: it's just making explicit a real and uncontroversial aspect of our psychological needs. If you spend 8 hours a day with an ******* boss and incompetent coworkers and then have an hour long drive home through ferocious traffic, but then you get home and feel comfortable and loved and valued, congratulations, that's your ****ing safe space. This idea that we need to put on our big boy pants because the real world is a mean place is bull****, because all of us have a place we go to when we're ****ing tired of dealing with the real world.
Except, actually, not all of us do. If you are a battered spouse or a gay kid with homophobic parents or what have you, then maybe not even home is a safe space. Then you rely on other spaces, either ones provided by the community or by friends or like-minded individuals.
Do maybe some people take this notion and run with it and talk about providing safe spaces from the great injustice of being mildly offended? Maybe. But who gives a ****? Stop getting so goddamn worked up when other dumb people do a dumb thing. Learn to roll your ****ing eyes and move on. Don't go whining about how the whole world has gone soft and kids these days and bla bla bla, because then you know what? Then you're waaaaaay overreacting to a minor problem, and hey what the hell does that sound like?
(The "you" here is not aimed at anyone here, but at the people I see on Facebook and Twitter who get frothy about this kind of stuff. This probably comes across as way harsher than I intended. But I'm tired and kind of in a bad mood for completely unrelated reasons, so I'm just going to hit post reply now and see what happens. Sorry.)
- Likes 3
Leave a comment:
-
-
There does appear to be something to what JM says, as well; wherever I go, it is mostly white (and gay) people getting apocalyptic. Black people, if they mention the lout at all, shrug and shake their heads. They're not the ones knitting, uh, "kitty" hats for the angry women's march on Inauguration Day. Too little experience with Latinos in my neck of the woods to draw even anecdotal conclusions, but if there's an angry Latino march I haven't heard of it.
Leave a comment:
-
"Safe spaces" is something that appears to be encouraged on college campuses these days.
Leave a comment:
-
Oh, it could go very badly. I always expect things to go badly, you know that. I'm mildly relieved that Trump's cabinet picks reveal an unimaginative troglo-conservatism. But there's no preparing for literally absolutely anything, and no immediate reason to suspect anything more terrible than an unusually crude and stupid version of standard GOP policy.Originally posted by Lorizael View PostYou talk about the moral arc there, and you seem to think people are naive for believing that the universe will naturally bend toward justice, but I think there is a very similar naivete in believing we all have to just suck it up and endure a mildly ****ty Trump presidency. For sufficiently terrible outcomes, not all of us get to endure it, and history does not have a habit of refraining from terrible outcomes.
Leave a comment:
-
I definitely do fear that our country and world are at risk because of Trump. That is because I fear his (and his associates) blatant corruption, concern only for winning, disregard for international order and having someone obviously unstable at the red button for a country with military ties throughout the globe.
It is clear to me that the people who are most concerned are the groups with the (I think) least to fear from Trump. Trump's rhetoric against the Muslims and Hispanics were some of the worst, yet both groups don't seem so concerned. African Americans have recently (1970s) experienced open attacks against their lives and property and don't see this as the end of the world, even though some Trump supporters seem to support returning to this situation.
No the groups that are the most concerned are white women who are one of the most privileged groups in the US (and who, as a group, supported Trump) and white homosexuals who have never experienced a sustained open attack against their lives and property in US history. Neither group are the focus of attack by Trump or his rabid supporters (the latter is under attack by Trump's recent allies in the religious right, but he has no intrinsic interest in their cause and did not attack them in his rhetoric). Not only that, but even the religious right mostly doesn't what to make homosexuality illegal and make an open attack on homosexuals lives and property but rather to have the right to be intolerant of homosexuals.
It does seem to be some sort of group narcism involved.
JM
(Once more, I am very frightened of Trump and wish the Electoral College had defended us against him, but that was purely for foreign policy and sovereignty reasons.)
(I like https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbeatG_M4JE )
Leave a comment:
-
The danger with Trump is perhaps longer term it the R machine accepts they have to play Trumps game to stay relevant. That is something that on a longer timeframe might lead to a generation where closer to half the population would follow a Trump like figure down the rabbit hole.
So really we should probably root for Trump to be as terrible as people fear he will be.
Leave a comment:
-
I think it's important to differentiate between those who voted FOR Trump, and those who voted R or AGAINST Hillary.
Trump may have around 20 million who really wouldn't care if he shot someone in Time square ... but the vast majority of Americans wouldn't let him get away with that.
He barely won the EC and lost the popular vote against a historically disliked candidate who was under investigation by the FBI just before the election. If he acts as if he has a mandate to do anything atrocious his own party would happily kick him out.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: