Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
The Moral Arc
Collapse
X
-
Do gay people have a right to receive conversion therapy kentonio? Maybe you should leave this to those who actually care about people's rights.
-
He chose a man (creature) for his vice-president who is a supporter of conversion therapy and one of the most vicious anti-gay ********* in the Republican party. Yes, its pretty safe to say that Trump doesn't give a **** about gay rights.Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
Trump didn't openly support anti-gay policies. He put someone on a list of possible nominees that is anti-gay and likely would vote for allowing states to make sodomy illegal. Even if he nominated Pryor it wouldn't mean that he doesn't care gay rights because he may nominate him for others reasons.
Leave a comment:
-
No. It's simple. Trump could appoint Pryor because of other issues besides this issue.Originally posted by Aeson View Post
You are mixing up the analogs.
Trump is to Pryor as voter is to Trump. Thus Pryor's view of homosexual rights is the analog to Trumps views on race. Trumps views on homosexuality are not.
Leave a comment:
-
It doesn't matter. I wasn't talking about losing to competitors although having limited choices is part of it. Trump could appoint Pryor and then not appoint too other judges with similarly offensive stances, so appointing Pryor is not anti-gay. It isn't pro gay rights, but it isn't anti-gay. This argument is coming from those who think that everything has to be pro gay rights.Originally posted by Aeson View PostSeveral others on his list are anti gay. Pryor reportedly is on the latest shortlist (of 5) ...
You are ignoring how Trump gets to hand pick his nominee... and doesn't have to worry that his nominee will lose to a competitors ... while voters can't do so while maintaining any hope of relevance of their vote.
Leave a comment:
-
You are mixing up the analogs.Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
Trump didn't openly support anti-gay policies. He put someone on a list of possible nominees that is anti-gay and likely would vote for allowing states to make sodomy illegal. Even if he nominated Pryor it wouldn't mean that he doesn't care gay rights because he may nominate him for others reasons.
So the analogy is perfect because most people who voted for Trump did so for some reason that has nothing to do with racism.
Trump is to Pryor as voter is to Trump. Thus Pryor's view of homosexual rights is the analog to Trumps views on race. Trumps views on homosexuality are not.
Leave a comment:
-
Several others on his list are anti gay. Pryor reportedly is on the latest shortlist (of 5) ...
You are ignoring how Trump gets to hand pick his nominee... and doesn't have to worry that his nominee will lose to a competitors ... while voters can't do so while maintaining any hope of relevance of their vote.
Leave a comment:
-
And even if he appoint 3 judges they won't all be anti-gay unless he is anti-gay and there is no evidence of that by any reasonable standard. Pryor is one possible out of 21. Why aren't the rest in favor of putting gays in jail?Originally posted by Aeson View Post
If you understand it then you know Trump has no vote in State legislatures, has no veto in state legislatures, and no vote in SCOTUS. Those are the arenas where this issue of state laws on sodomy are decided on.
Even on a federal level if a law were introduced he at most has veto power that Congress can override.
You would also know that Trump will at most be in office 8 years, while his SCOTUS appointments could last decades.
The only real input Trump has on the issue is who he nominates, and his list of potential nominees is very telling.
Leave a comment:
-
Trump didn't openly support anti-gay policies. He put someone on a list of possible nominees that is anti-gay and likely would vote for allowing states to make sodomy illegal. Even if he nominated Pryor it wouldn't mean that he doesn't care gay rights because he may nominate him for others reasons.Originally posted by Aeson View PostThat analogy only works if we accept the premise that Trump had openly admitted to supporting racist policies. Is that what you are claiming?
Because Pryor has, on public record, expressed his view that it is ok to jail homosexuals for having sex in their own homes. You can't divorce yourself from what you are very clearly in support of.
So the analogy is perfect because most people who voted for Trump did so for some reason that has nothing to do with racism.
Leave a comment:
-
I should note that even if we accept that, it's still not a valid analogy. This is because a voter in the presidential election has virtually no choice in who has a viable chance at winning, and so "lesser of two evils" is a legitimate reason to vote for someone you disagree with. However, Trump has almost free reign to pick the nominees he thinks are best for the job. So who he picks is far more telling about his own positions.Originally posted by Aeson View PostThat analogy only works if we accept the premise that Trump had openly admitted to supporting racist policies. Is that what you are claiming?
Because Pryor has, on public record, expressed his view that it is ok to jail homosexuals for having sex in their own homes. You can't divorce yourself from what you are very clearly in support of.
Leave a comment:
-
If you understand it then you know Trump has no vote in State legislatures, has no veto in state legislatures, and no vote in SCOTUS. Those are the arenas where this issue of state laws on sodomy are decided on.Originally posted by Kidicious View Post
No. I understand it fine. Another tactic by you.
Even on a federal level if a law were introduced he at most has veto power that Congress can override.
You would also know that Trump will at most be in office 8 years, while his SCOTUS appointments could last decades.
The only real input Trump has on the issue is who he nominates, and his list of potential nominees is very telling.
Leave a comment:
-
That analogy only works if we accept the premise that Trump had openly admitted to supporting racist policies. Is that what you are claiming?
Because Pryor has, on public record, expressed his view that it is ok to jail homosexuals for having sex in their own homes. You can't divorce yourself from what you are very clearly in support of.
Leave a comment:
-
No it isn't. This is basically the same thing as saying that a vote for Trump is a vote for racism.Originally posted by Aeson View PostAlso if Trump thinks it's a good idea to have Pryor or similar on the court, it is an admission he doesn't care about homosexual rights.
Leave a comment:
-
No. I understand it fine. Another tactic by you.Originally posted by Aeson View Post
Trump is not SCOTUS, nor is he state legislatures. You don't seem to understand our government at all.
Leave a comment:
-
Also if Trump thinks it's a good idea to have Pryor or similar on the court, it is an admission he doesn't care about homosexual rights.
Leave a comment:
-
Trump is not SCOTUS, nor is he state legislatures. You don't seem to understand our government at all.Originally posted by Kidicious View PostIf Trump doesn't want gays to be thrown in jail there's basically no chance that that is going to happen, yet you are going on as though it were a real possibility. This is what gets my goat, and if I tell liberals that they act like I'm homophobic. I'm not homophobic because I don't buy into your scare tactic.
Leave a comment:
Leave a comment: