Review Me

St Leo · September 1, 2003, 14:49

This Thread

Give us links to stuff you want reviewed, post reviews-in-progress for comment, and generally pig out on review.

Reviewing Policies and Reviewing

Please take the time to read our guidelines for review writing and download the current version (1.1) of the reviewing form, in Rich Text Format or as a .ZIP

Update: Regretfully, Blackclove is no longer with Sleague. Please submit your reviews to petraziATsympaticoDOTca and darthvedaAThotmailDOTcom.

Case · September 1, 2003, 23:16

I'd appreciate a full fledged review of my scenario 'Raging Dragon'. I'm thinking of releasing an update, but am not sure what to add or remove.
[I wish I hadn't accidently deleted the email some guy sent me on exactly that topic - as well as being interesting, I hadn't replyed to him yet

]

Cal · September 2, 2003, 22:06

Originally posted by Case
I'd appreciate a full fledged review of my scenario 'Raging Dragon'. I'm thinking of releasing an update, but am not sure what to add or remove.
[I wish I hadn't accidently deleted the email some guy sent me on exactly that topic - as well as being interesting, I hadn't replyed to him yet

]

That's not me, is it? I sent you an e-mail about that, and I did get a reply...

If you want me to resend, I can do that.

techumseh · September 3, 2003, 00:02

I'd offer up Red October for a review. It's a ToT scenario, and is available on my site, here: http://www.tecumseh.150m.com/

Case · September 3, 2003, 02:04

Originally posted by Cal

That's not me, is it? I sent you an e-mail about that, and I did get a reply...

If you want me to resend, I can do that.

I'm pretty sure that I've still got your email. The one I deleted had a lot of excelent feedback on unit stats.

DarthVeda · September 4, 2003, 00:07

It'd sure be nice if some people reviewed some of my scenarios

http://darthveda.tripod.com/

Peaster · September 4, 2003, 11:41

Well, I could do a review or two. I'd prefer MGE fantasy or sci-fi scenarios, or ones by newcomers like myself. Somebody else could surely do a better job than I on most historical ones (which Raging Dragon is, I assume?). Suggestions welcomed.

DarthVeda - I'll try your Gangwars scenario, if you like.

Stefan Härtel · September 5, 2003, 15:49

Well, I'd always like to have my scenarios reviewed...
http://www.alexanderthegreat.de/civ2/index.html

Goingonit · September 5, 2003, 17:26

DarthVeda- I'm playing your Sengoku Jidai scen and I'll write up a review for it if you want.

Henrik · September 6, 2003, 01:25

Anyone who wishes could review 'de Historibus Europae

DarthVeda · September 6, 2003, 10:56

yes, please do

Peaster · September 13, 2003, 19:34

OK. I've just submitted a review of Darth's 1998 PG13 Gangwars scenario.

Lots of bad guys in this scenario.

Arthedain · September 13, 2003, 19:51

Originally posted by Peaster
OK. I've just submitted a review of Darth's 1998 PG13 Gangwars scenario.

Where can we find this scenario?

Peaster · September 13, 2003, 20:13

You can find it at Darth's web site. There's also a 1999 review of it by Cam Hills in the SL archives.

http://darthveda.tripod.com/

Cal · September 27, 2003, 03:57

I just got through playing Harlan Thompson's WWII in Europe scenario all the way to the end.

It's old, but I finally got a decisive victory.

I will write a review.

DarthVeda · September 27, 2003, 22:08

new review up today folks

tonic · September 30, 2003, 21:08

I'm interested in the unusual Biological Evolution mod/scenario by Charles Magee Jr. http://www.castle.net/~cwmagee/civ2.html and in whether anyone has seen a in depth review of it. It has potential although my first impression was that the maintenance costs of some of the improvements were a tad high.

DarthVeda · November 7, 2003, 11:59

So we could sure use some more reviews...

Varwnos · December 15, 2003, 07:57

so deleted...

Patine · February 12, 2004, 13:21

I actually did a 'Late Cold War' scenario recently, got an excellent review, and have made several changes, notably in units. The introductory text hasn't been fully updated, and I have yet to compose a good readme, but its still in development after all. A feature that's not obvious (I absent-mindedly neglected to mention it in the introduction) is the diplomatic victory option (which replaces the spaceship), that essentially has renamed advances, improvements, wonder, and labels for (just ignore the old cinematic), including the United Nations wonder as the Apollo Program (for coming to the fore in, not founding the UN), and Peacekeeping Missions, New Embassies, and Popular Declarations instead of spaceship parts. Its on a gigaworld map with mostly high-res graphics. I don't have an active web site, so I'll post it here on this thread. Please e-mail any comments or reviews to chandallah@netscape.net.

Elok · March 14, 2004, 18:24

Broken Kingdom:

http://apolyton.net/forums/showthrea...hreadid=110486

I don't have an online host, so this is its "home"...

St Leo · March 24, 2004, 14:41

The stuff people have submitted to me will go up someday. Honest. Just not today. Or this weekend. Or whatever.

DarkCloud · June 20, 2004, 21:19

how's it coming along Leo?

Heresson · September 28, 2004, 16:55

Originally posted by Stefan Härtel
Well, I'd always like to have my scenarios reviewed...
http://www.alexanderthegreat.de/civ2/index.html

You should update your site
Of all the scns listed there, I could download only two.
Also, your lastest works doesn't seem to be there
Do something about it!

conmcb25 · September 29, 2004, 18:07

I dont think St Leo likes us anymore

curtsibling · September 30, 2004, 05:07

Cthulhu has abandoned us!

Cyrion · September 30, 2004, 05:27

Originally posted by curtsibling
Cthulhu has abandoned us!

He is too busy preparing for the november presidential election...

St Leo · December 13, 2004, 00:08

Originally posted by DarkCloud
how's it coming along Leo?

I am not sure. Could you remind me?

Peaster · December 13, 2004, 11:12

I have been more interested in strategy/playing civ2 lately, but would still be willing to review a scenario or two upon request.

BTW - Could anyone recommend a scenario that would work well in a monthly tournament (see the Apolyton -General forum ) ? I think something similar to normal civ2 would be easier for most of the players to digest.