Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 31 to 60 of 77

Thread: Why did both Napoleon and Hitler fail to defeat Russia?

  1. #31
    germanos
    King germanos's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Apr 2002
    Location
    Behind a dike, Holland
    Posts
    2,820
    Country
    This is germanos's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    11:36
    Originally posted by GePap


    The theory of a planned Soviet attack aganist the Germans has been disproven by historians that have looked through the Red Army archives. As for the Soviets having the bulk of their forces close to the border: well, were else would you put them if you have Nazi germany as a neighbor? In Siberia?
    Given the nature of Blitzkrieg-tactics AND the fact you have a Non-Agression Pact, I see no objection to stationing them in Siberia

  2. #32
    Dr Strangelove
    Emperor Dr Strangelove's Avatar
    Join Date
    31 Dec 1969
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    7,136
    Thanks
    4
    Thanked 57 Times in 48 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    04:36
    Originally posted by Andrew1999
    What would have happened if Napoleon had advanced up the coast to St. Petersburg instead of to Moscow?
    Napoleon's experience with the British had left hi a little irrational on the subjesty of coastlines. Even though St. Petersburg had become the capital of Russia in the 17th century Napoleon decided to shoot for Moscow because he feared that marching on St. Petersburg would have left one flank of his Grand Armee open to attack by the British!
    "I say shoot'em all and let God sort it out in the end!

  3. #33
    Serb
    Emperor Serb's Avatar
    Join Date
    02 Nov 2001
    Location
    Siberia, Communist party of Apolyton
    Posts
    6,090
    Country
    This is Serb's Country Flag
    Thanks
    27
    Thanked 21 Times in 21 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    16:36
    All is simple- because no one, never was able to conquer Russia and no one ever will. Because- Russkie ne zdayutsya.
    The rest is bullsh!t.
    Nu chto, podbrosish druga svoego zaklyatogo na svoem gorbu k vorotam raya zvezndo-polosatogo?
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_na1JMpeF8

  4. #34
    Serb
    Emperor Serb's Avatar
    Join Date
    02 Nov 2001
    Location
    Siberia, Communist party of Apolyton
    Posts
    6,090
    Country
    This is Serb's Country Flag
    Thanks
    27
    Thanked 21 Times in 21 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    16:36
    Originally posted by jimmytrick
    He refused to allow tactical retreat or defensive measures.
    In memouirs of one very high ranked German general who served in feildmarshal von Kluge HQ iirc, I've read that he consider that this Hitler's decision SAVED German army from collapse. He says that if Hitler didn't gave this order Wermach would shared the fate of great Napoleon army.
    Nu chto, podbrosish druga svoego zaklyatogo na svoem gorbu k vorotam raya zvezndo-polosatogo?
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S_na1JMpeF8

  5. #35
    Urban Ranger
    Deity Urban Ranger's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 May 1999
    Location
    The City State of Noosphere, CPA special envoy
    Posts
    14,613
    Country
    This is Urban Ranger's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 2 Times in 1 Post
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    17:36

    Sick

    Originally posted by Serb
    All is simple- because no one, never was able to conquer Russia and no one ever will. Because- Russkie ne zdayutsya.
    The rest is bullsh!t.
    Surely? Genghis Khan kicked your butts pretty good.
    (\__/) 07/07/1937 - Never forget
    (='.'=) "Claims demand evidence; extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence." -- Carl Sagan
    (")_(") "Starting the fire from within."

  6. #36
    DinoDoc
    Deity DinoDoc's Avatar
    Join Date
    30 Sep 1999
    Location
    100% WOLF
    Posts
    17,623
    Thanks
    82
    Thanked 275 Times in 211 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    03:36

    Sick

    Originally posted by Serb
    All is simple- because no one, never was able to conquer Russia and no one ever will. Because- Russkie ne zdayutsya.
    The Kaiser fared pretty well against your army and he had less troops on that front than Hitler.
    I make no bones about my moral support for [terrorist] organizations. - chegitz guevara
    For those who aspire to live in a high cost, high tax, big government place, our nation and the world offers plenty of options. Vermont, Canada and Venezuela all offer you the opportunity to live in the socialist, big government paradise you long for. –Senator Rubio

  7. #37
    Az
    Emperor
    Join Date
    23 Apr 2000
    Location
    Connecticut
    Posts
    3,753
    Country
    This is Az's Country Flag
    Thanks
    18
    Thanked 4 Times in 3 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    12:36
    Surely? Genghis Khan kicked your butts pretty good.
    I wouldn't start waving my penis yet, both of you, UR and Serb. the line above is right for both of you.

    Actually, I think that Russia would benefit greatly if it would have been defeated by Napoleon. And IIRC, napoleon wasn't the one to declare war on Russia.

    Napoleon

  8. #38
    Urban Ranger
    Deity Urban Ranger's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 May 1999
    Location
    The City State of Noosphere, CPA special envoy
    Posts
    14,613
    Country
    This is Urban Ranger's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 2 Times in 1 Post
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    17:36
    But who kicked the Mongols out first? We did.
    (\__/) 07/07/1937 - Never forget
    (='.'=) "Claims demand evidence; extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence." -- Carl Sagan
    (")_(") "Starting the fire from within."

  9. #39
    Urban Ranger
    Deity Urban Ranger's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 May 1999
    Location
    The City State of Noosphere, CPA special envoy
    Posts
    14,613
    Country
    This is Urban Ranger's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 2 Times in 1 Post
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    17:36
    I read somewhere that the reason why Napoleon lost so badly was he didn't have proper shoes for his troops.
    (\__/) 07/07/1937 - Never forget
    (='.'=) "Claims demand evidence; extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence." -- Carl Sagan
    (")_(") "Starting the fire from within."

  10. #40
    Dauphin
    Deity Dauphin's Avatar
    Join Date
    31 Dec 1969
    Location
    Puteaux, France
    Posts
    13,379
    Country
    This is Dauphin's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 101 Times in 65 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    11:36
    The French lost because they were French.
    The Germans lost because they tried to take everyone on at once.
    Capitalisation - The difference between helping your uncle Jack off a horse, and helping your uncle jack off a horse
    Grammar - The difference between knowing your $hit, and knowing you're $hit.
    Spelling - The difference between being literate, and being Dinner.

  11. #41
    Arrian
    Deity Arrian's Avatar
    Join Date
    04 Jul 2001
    Location
    Kneel before Grog!
    Posts
    18,540
    Country
    This is Arrian's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    04:36
    Invasions of Russia are badly hampered by weather and the immense size of the country. Supplying one's troops becomes incredibly difficult.

    Napolean and Hitler lost because both bit off more (much more) than they could chew.

    -Arrian
    grog want tank...Grog Want Tank... GROG WANT TANK!

    The trick isn't to break some eggs to make an omelette, it's convincing the eggs to break themselves in order to aspire to omelettehood.

  12. #42
    orange
    Emperor orange's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Feb 2000
    Location
    It doesn't matter what your name is!
    Posts
    3,605
    Country
    This is orange's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    05:36
    cold, and lots of it!
    "Chegitz, still angry about the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991?
    You provide no source. You PROVIDE NOTHING! And yet you want to destroy capitalism.. you criminal..." - Fez

    "I was hoping for a Communist utopia that would last forever." - Imran Siddiqui

  13. #43
    Capt Dizle
    King
    Join Date
    17 Sep 1999
    Posts
    1,657
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    04:36
    Russian women are so ugly that French and German troops lost the will to fight. Why bother.

  14. #44
    Inverse Icarus
    Emperor Inverse Icarus's Avatar
    Join Date
    23 May 2001
    Location
    flying too low to the ground
    Posts
    4,625
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    04:36
    Supply / Long Distances / Underestimating the Cold.
    "I've lived too long with pain. I won't know who I am without it. We have to leave this place, I am almost happy here."
    - Ender, from Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card

  15. #45
    Andrew1999
    Warlord Andrew1999's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Aug 2001
    Posts
    146
    Country
    This is Andrew1999's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    03:36
    Of course, the all time worst invasion of Russia would have to be the Russian Civil War interventions by the Allies.


  16. #46
    Az
    Emperor
    Join Date
    23 Apr 2000
    Location
    Connecticut
    Posts
    3,753
    Country
    This is Az's Country Flag
    Thanks
    18
    Thanked 4 Times in 3 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    12:36

    Wink

    Russian women are so ugly that French and German troops lost the will to fight. Why bother.

    God have mercy on this deluded lost soul.




    UGLY:
    Attached Images Attached Images

  17. #47
    Demerzel
    Warlord
    Join Date
    31 Jul 2002
    Posts
    219
    Country
    This is Demerzel's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    09:36
    Many causes why Hitler lost.

    He attacked too late in the year and thus had his troops face incredible hardships because of his stubborness.

    He constantly interfered in military decisions, often overriding his generals when he felt the need. Example of this was that one of the panzer generals was pushing hell for leather for Moscow but was told to turn back and help in the encirclement of prisoners. Result - lots of prisoners captured ( millions even ) but Moscow was fortified and reinforced before the Germans eventually got there.

    He forced Germany to fight a war on two fronts, by leaving England still in the fight he seriously degraded his striking power that he could have used against Russia.

    Supply of troops was hard, transferring stuff by rail was hard as rail gauge for Europe & Russia is different - Europe is standard gauge & Russia wide IIRC.

    Finally,

    Originally posted by Serb

    Originally posted by jimmytrick
    He refused to allow tactical retreat or defensive measures.
    In memouirs of one very high ranked German general who served in feildmarshal von Kluge HQ iirc, I've read that he consider that this Hitler's decision SAVED German army from collapse. He says that if Hitler didn't gave this order Wermach would shared the fate of great Napoleon army.
    Yes I read about this too somewhere else, Hitler in forcing his troops to hold their ground prevented them from routing and kept the Wehrmacht from collapsing. However, by this action even though he saved the army structure he condemned tens of thousands or hundred thousands of german men to injury or death. He saved the army itself but lost half the men doing so. Ouch.

  18. #48
    Sandman
    King Sandman's Avatar
    Join Date
    05 Aug 2001
    Location
    Just one more thing
    Posts
    1,734
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    10:36
    Hitlers failure could attributed to the failure of the pro-German Yugoslav government to maintain power. Germany had to invade Yugoslavia pushing back the Russian invasion five weeks. With those five weeks, the Germans would have surely taken Moscow. Stalin would have been forced to sue for peace.
    If this had not happened, then the Germans would not have invaded Greece, meaning that British could probably have taken Tripoli and wrapped up North Africa. From there, the Greeks could be reinforced even more and Italy would probably be forced out of Albania.

    Then what happens? As has been said, Germany's airforce would be in better shape, but it's units would also be less experienced, and they may still have a belief in the utility of paratroops, perhaps using them at a key battle, only to find out that paratroops are not as effective as one might think.

    Britain is not tied up fighting Rommel in North Africa, and is able to mess about somewhere else. I doubt an invasion of France by Britain alone is on the cards though. A strike against Norway, or maybe Italy. Liberating Norway would certainly help supplies reach Russia. Rommel, meanwhile, is able to work his magic on the Eastern Front.

    That's as far as I can see, I'm afraid.

  19. #49
    Andrew1999
    Warlord Andrew1999's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Aug 2001
    Posts
    146
    Country
    This is Andrew1999's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    03:36
    I'm not sure I buy that timeline. Hitler decided to invade Greece before the coup (to rescue Musssolini), it was only a matter of whether or not Yugoslavia would cooperate with his troops moving through the country. Conquering Yugoslavia only added a few days to the schedule. So with no coup Germany and Italy still end up in control of Greece by about the same date, with Yugoslavia on board as another junior member of the Axis.

    If Mussolini had never invaded Greece in the first place, or had been successful, things would have been different. If Italy never invaded I doubt Greece would break neutrality by inviting in the British; they could seet the likely results in Western Europe. If Italy's invasion of mainland Greece was successful, I doubt they could take over all the islands and Crete for example would probably remain in British hands.

  20. #50
    ixnay
    Emperor ixnay's Avatar
    Join Date
    31 Dec 1998
    Location
    Seattle, WA
    Posts
    3,220
    Country
    This is ixnay's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    02:36
    Easy: The "Russian Winter" causes double attrition damage to invading enemy troops. This, combined with their ability to gather oil 10% faster than anyone else, makes them very tough to invade.


  21. #51
    Jon Shafer
    Firaxis Games Programmer/Designer
    Join Date
    09 Apr 2002
    Location
    Maryland
    Posts
    9,566
    Country
    This is Jon Shafer's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    05:36
    Germany lost to the USSR for a variety of reasons; poor planning and Hitler's interference are the main ones though.

    Napoleon lost for one reason: He fought the war with Russia like he fought every other war. March for territory, live off the land, and threaten the enemy's capital. Unfortunately the Russian Army and the Russian nation weren't defeated yet, so Napoleon ended up losing. He figured if he took Moscow (like he had done with Berlin and nearly Vienna about a half dozen times) then Russia would capitulate. If he had known better, then he would have accounted for all of the other problems that popped up.

  22. #52
    Sandman
    King Sandman's Avatar
    Join Date
    05 Aug 2001
    Location
    Just one more thing
    Posts
    1,734
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    10:36
    I'm not sure I buy that timeline. Hitler decided to invade Greece before the coup (to rescue Musssolini), it was only a matter of whether or not Yugoslavia would cooperate with his troops moving through the country. Conquering Yugoslavia only added a few days to the schedule. So with no coup Germany and Italy still end up in control of Greece by about the same date, with Yugoslavia on board as another junior member of the Axis.
    Ah, well then I'm mostly wrong then. Still, it was an enormous blunder not taking Tripoli when we had the chance.

  23. #53
    chequita guevara
    Emperor chequita guevara's Avatar
    Join Date
    19 Jun 2000
    Location
    Fort LOLderdale, FL Communist Party of Apolyton
    Posts
    9,175
    Thanks
    9
    Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    05:36
    Originally posted by Lawrence of Arabia
    Hitler didnt assemble enought divisions. He could have taken Moscow on the first attempt. He also could have invaded 21 days earlier.
    No he couldn't have. It rains in May in Russia and the country turns to mud. It takes several weeks for the country to dry out enough for trucks to be able to drive on Russian dirt roads. Had the invasion been launched any sooner, the armor would have quickly outpaced their resupply ability, the Soviets would have counter-attacked, and Germany would have been defeated in 1941.
    Christianity: The belief that a cosmic Jewish Zombie who was his own father can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magical tree...

  24. #54
    chequita guevara
    Emperor chequita guevara's Avatar
    Join Date
    19 Jun 2000
    Location
    Fort LOLderdale, FL Communist Party of Apolyton
    Posts
    9,175
    Thanks
    9
    Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    05:36
    Originally posted by Azazel
    God have mercy on this deluded lost soul.
    Russian women start out gorgeous, then the get older. Krupskaya was a total babe in her youth. Russia is hard on its women.
    Christianity: The belief that a cosmic Jewish Zombie who was his own father can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magical tree...

  25. #55
    Capt Dizle
    King
    Join Date
    17 Sep 1999
    Posts
    1,657
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    04:36
    Originally posted by Azazel


    God have mercy on this deluded lost soul.




    UGLY:
    But she looks like a drunken German grabbed a housefrau one cold night.

  26. #56
    Az
    Emperor
    Join Date
    23 Apr 2000
    Location
    Connecticut
    Posts
    3,753
    Country
    This is Az's Country Flag
    Thanks
    18
    Thanked 4 Times in 3 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    12:36
    Russian women start out gorgeous, then the get older.
    agreed!

  27. #57
    Bereta_Eder
    King Bereta_Eder's Avatar
    Join Date
    11 Oct 2000
    Posts
    2,099
    Thanks
    64
    Thanked 63 Times in 59 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    11:36
    Geramny had to divert troops to Greece because Italy failed to capture Greece.

    That slowed the invasion of Germany to Russia. And Hitler did it in the harsh winter.

    I'm not saying that if it wasnt done in winter Germany would have won.

    Im saying that we did help the russians by defeating Italy and (unfortunately) forcing Germany to assist them and delay them.

    Yes after that dodecanese passed from Italy to Greece. Also S. Albania would have also passed to Greece but it didnt. Greece had 2/3s of Albania in its command sicne the Greco-Italian war happened mainly in Albania.
    During trying times, rage is a better councelor than remorse.

  28. #58
    Bereta_Eder
    King Bereta_Eder's Avatar
    Join Date
    11 Oct 2000
    Posts
    2,099
    Thanks
    64
    Thanked 63 Times in 59 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    11:36
    And Im pretty sure that were it not for Italy attacking Greece, Greece would not have been involved in that war.

    It was a pissing contest between England and Germany for which many countries suffered from it. Yugoslavia also.
    During trying times, rage is a better councelor than remorse.

  29. #59
    Tolls
    King Tolls's Avatar
    Join Date
    31 Dec 1969
    Location
    Hereford, UK
    Posts
    2,184
    Country
    This is Tolls's Country Flag
    Thanks
    0
    Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    10:36
    "It rains in May in Russia and the country turns to mud. "

    Beat me to it..

    In Russia May is worse than November as far as mechanised forces are concerned...though I would hesitate to go quite so far as to say Germany loses in '41!

    As for Greece, as Paiktis says, they had no intention on getting involved...Metaxas refused Churchills offer of support because he didn't want to annoy the Germans, so there's no reason to assume he (or his successor) would suddenly declare war.

    Now...Napoleon....

    Strangelove said something earlier about heading for St Petersburg, and Napoleon's fear of the coast (or words to that effect)...the main reason for not going for St Petersburg as the main thrust (there was a force sent that way, Bavarians mainly, as a flanking guard) was that there is a very large fortress in the way at Riga, which is not easy tp besiege because of its sea access (in fact it would have been impossible).

    Trip brings up an important point about Napoleon...he always, always, ALWAYS went for the capital on the basis that the enemy would then surrender...and everytime it failed! Everytime he had to fight one more battle (at least) before that country surrendered (Austerlitz, Friedland, Wagram). He never learnt...and finally in Russia (and Spain) he came a cropper when he simply ran out of strength to fight that final battle.

  30. #60
    Bereta_Eder
    King Bereta_Eder's Avatar
    Join Date
    11 Oct 2000
    Posts
    2,099
    Thanks
    64
    Thanked 63 Times in 59 Posts
    Local Date
    November 28, 2014
    Local Time
    11:36
    Originally posted by Tolls
    As for Greece, as Paiktis says, they had no intention on getting involved...Metaxas refused Churchills offer of support because he didn't want to annoy the Germans, so there's no reason to assume he (or his successor) would suddenly declare war.
    He also refused the offer by Italy and Germany to join their side.
    During trying times, rage is a better councelor than remorse.

Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast

Similar Threads

  1. Can we defeat Russia?
    By Asher in forum Off Topic
    Replies: 48
    Last Post: November 26, 2008, 15:31
  2. Replies: 17
    Last Post: July 27, 2008, 20:19
  3. Replies: 19
    Last Post: August 31, 2005, 12:18
  4. Help! I continue to fail.....
    By Ision in forum Civ3-General-Archive
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: May 19, 2003, 07:40
  5. Did the UN fail?
    By GePap in forum Off-Topic-Archive
    Replies: 238
    Last Post: April 21, 2003, 00:09

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions